You are here:

House of Lords Library

Access to Palliative Care Bill [HL]: Briefing for Lords Stages

Published Wednesday, June 5, 2019

This House of Lords Library Briefing has been prepared in advance of the second reading in the House of Lords of the Access to Palliative Care Bill [HL], scheduled to take place on 14 June 2019.

Jump to full report >>

The Access to Palliative Care Bill [HL] is a private member’s bill introduced by Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (Crossbench). The bill had its first reading in the House of Lords on 5 July 2017. It is scheduled to receive its second reading on 14 June 2019.

Key Provisions

The bill aims to “make provision for clinical commissioning groups [CCGs] to ensure that persons in their area have access to specialist and generalist palliative care and appropriate support services”. If enacted, the bill would:

  • Require CCGs to ensure that individuals with palliative care needs have access to “appropriate health services”. This obligation would include, but not be limited to ensuring:
    • access to pain and symptom management;
    • psychological support for individuals and their relatives; and
    • information regarding an individual’s condition and palliative care.
  • Place a duty on CCGs to prepare and publish a strategy on providing for such palliative care needs. The strategy would have to set out information including the expected palliative care needs of adults and children in the relevant CCG’s area. Also, how these needs would be met; and under what circumstances and how specialist palliative care services would be provided.

The bill’s provisions would extend to England only.

Background and Recent Developments

Baroness Finlay introduced iterations of her Access to Palliative Care Bill [HL] in previous sessions. They were wider in scope than the current bill. The 2006–07 and 2015–16 versions completed their stages in the House of Lords before falling in the House of Commons. The 2016–17 version of the bill, meanwhile, did not progress beyond first reading.

Speaking during the 2015–16 bill’s second reading debate, Baroness Finlay cited evidence that provision of palliative care in England was “unacceptably patchy”. She observed wide variation in the commissioned levels of palliative care services across the country. Baroness Finlay set out the case for a statutory duty on CCGs in relation to palliative care needs as follows:

The demands on CCGs are great. They are well intentioned, but drowning. They need a clear, simple template to bring up the standard of services. Importantly, patients and their families, faced with all the fears and uncertainties of discovering that this is likely to be their final illness, need and deserve the assurance that their care will be good and that they will not be abandoned or failed in their hour of need, wherever they are, whatever the time or day of the week.

Lord Hunt of King’s Heath, speaking in the debate on behalf of the Opposition, “warmly welcome[d]” the bill. However, Lord Prior of Brampton, Parliamentary Under Secretary at the Department of Health, stated that the Government could not support the bill. He said this was despite the Government being in “full agreement” with its underlying intentions. The “most important reason” for this was the Government’s view that palliative care was an issue “best tackled by clinicians, ideally together with patients, carers and loved ones”. This would be “based on a combination of the patient’s individual condition, [their] preferences and the clinician’s professional expertise”. Lord Prior added that the bill went “against the whole concept and principle of local autonomy that was established in primary legislation through the Health and Social Care Act 2012”. 

More recently, the NHS Long Term Plan, published in January 2019, committed that the NHS would “introduce proactive and personalised care planning for everyone identified as being in their last year of life”. This would support a “reduction in avoidable emergency admissions and more people being able to die in a place they have chosen”. To deliver on this commitment, the Government has reiterated its view that ultimately the “funding and commissioning of palliative and end of life care is a local matter, over which individual NHS commissioners have responsibility”.

Lords Library notes LLN-2019-0068

Author: Thomas Brown

Topic: Health services

Share this page

Stay up to date

  • Subscribe to RSS feed Subscribe to Email alerts Lords Library notes

House of Lords Library

The House of Lords Library delivers research and information services to Members and staff of the House in support of parliamentary business.