This Commons Library briefing paper provides an outline of the current position relating to grammar schools and proposed Government reforms. It covers England only. The paper also outlines recent support and opposition to the establishment of new grammar schools, and research on their impact.Jump to full report >>
It is currently unlawful to open entirely new grammar schools in England.
On 6 August 2016, the Telegraph reported that the Prime Minister planned to end this ban and on 9 September 2016 this was confirmed. The Government says it plans to give the ‘green light’ to the expansion of existing grammars, and allow existing non-selective schools to become selective in certain circumstances.
The Government would consult on proposals:
The consultation, Schools that work for everyone, was subsequently published on 12 September 2016. The consultation closed on 12 December 2016.
The Conservative manifesto for the 2017 General Election stated that the party intended to lift the ban on new selective schools, subject to conditions.
Following the loss of the Conservative majority at the election, the proposals did not appear in the Queen’s Speech in June 2017, and the Government subsequently confirmed that the ban on new grammar schools would remain in place.
The Chancellor’s Autumn Statement on 23 November 2016 announced £200m of funding for selective school expansion. The Selective School Expansion Fund has been established to allocate the first £50m of this during 2018-19, with applications open until 19 July 2018.
Existing grammar schools are currently permitted to expand, including on to new sites, and there have been several recent proposals for these kinds of expansions. In December 2013, two proposals for the establishment of a satellite grammar school in Sevenoaks, one submitted by Weald of Kent Grammar School in Tonbridge and the other by Invicta Grammar School in Maidstone, were rejected by the then Education Secretary, Michael Gove.
In the case of the Weald of Kent Grammar School, it was reported that this was because the annex school was planned to be co-educational, whereas the parent school was single-sex.
In a written ministerial statement on 15 October 2015 the then Education Secretary, Nicky Morgan, announced that she had approved a revised proposal from the Weald of Kent Grammar School to expand onto a satellite site in Sevenoaks, several miles from the original school site.
On 19 October 2015, Nicky Morgan made an oral statement further setting out some of the reasoning behind her decision.
Grammar schools select all or most of their pupils based on examination of their academic ability, usually at age 11.
Grammar schools, and schools that have had unchanged partially selective admissions arrangements in place since the 1997-98 school year, are permitted to continue to select pupils on the basis of their academic ability.
A maintained school may select on the basis of aptitude if:
Selection by ability is prohibited for all other local authority maintained schools, other than for banding and selection to sixth forms.
Converter academies that were previously designated as grammar schools or had partially selective arrangements when in the local authority maintained sector can continue to be selective.
Apart from for these exceptions, under the Academies Act 2010 all academies must provide for children of different abilities (i.e. be ‘comprehensive’).
This means that selective independent schools wishing to become free schools will not be able to select by ability as free schools.
The general restriction on selection by ability for state funded schools means that no new grammar schools may be created.
It is possible, however, for existing grammar schools to expand.
Changes to the School Admissions Code made in 2012, and retained in the updated December 2014 version, made it easier for schools, including grammar schools, to expand their numbers.
One of the changes enabled schools to increase their Published Admission Number (PAN) without the need for consultation.
The admissions code applies to academies and free schools as well as local authority maintained schools.
Under January 2014 regulations, governing bodies of all maintained schools can enlarge the school premises without the need for a statutory process in some circumstances.
This applies to grammar schools as to other local authority maintained schools.
Before making any changes, governing bodies must ensure that a number of criteria are fulfilled, including that the admissions authority is content for the published admissions number (PAN) to be changed where this forms part of expansion plans.
Expansions that do not require a physical enlargement to the premises of the school are not covered by the regulations. Such an increase in pupil numbers may be achieved solely by increasing the PAN in line with the School Admissions Code.
In the case of community, foundation and voluntary schools, local authorities can also propose that a school’s premises be enlarged by following a streamlined statutory process set out in regulations.
Academies wishing to enlarge their premises need to seek approval from the Secretary of State, through the Education Funding Agency (EFA). They are generally not required to submit a formal business case to the EFA unless the expansion is very large scale or takes pupil numbers over 2,000.
Those proposing the expansion of an existing local authority maintained school onto an additional site “need to ensure that the new provision is genuinely a change to an existing school and not a new school”.
Similarly, information on the stages of the statutory process states that the expansion of an existing academy onto a satellite state “will only be approved if it is a genuine continuance of the same school.”
The same criteria are listed as being used by the Secretary of State when deciding whether to approve the expansion of academy schools onto satellite sites.
Sections 104 to 109 of the School Standards and Framework Act 1998 make provision for parental ballots to determine whether particular grammar schools or groups of grammar schools should retain their selective admission arrangements.
A ballot can only be held if at least 20% of eligible parents have signed a petition requesting such a ballot. The detailed arrangements for the ballot are set out in regulations.
Governing bodies of local authority maintained grammar schools may also propose ending the selective admission arrangements at a grammar school by following a statutory process. Information on the stages of the statutory process is provided in Department for Education guidance.
Provisions allowing governing bodies of maintained grammar schools to propose removing selection, and provisions relating to parental ballots, do not apply to academies.
Selective schools that convert to academy status are required to remain subject to the same provisions for removing selection as they were subject to as a maintained school, through their funding agreements.
Further information about the support and opposition of grammar schools can be found in the associated PDF.
Further information about the evolution of grammar schools since 1944 can be found in the associated PDF.
Commons Briefing papers SN07070
Authors: David Foster; Robert Long; Nerys Roberts